"...The Genesis Theory of Creationism is more 'naturalistic' than evolution" So wait, you're saying that the supernatural is natural? Evolution doesn't have or use any supernatural explanations, so even in that context what you're saying is a direct contradiction.
The issue is NOT that evolutionists run out of 'naturalistic' explanations for their faith. The problem is that each explanation does not qualify as being 'naturalistic' when using their own criteria: http://www.whoisyourcreator.com/scientific_criteria.html