I don't think you were harsh at all! the tone here has always been good-natured, then all of a sudden there were these people attacking anyone who said they loved AGOS, and even sneaking attacks on Robert. That's just not cool.
Personally, I'll defend Robert and root for him even if I don't like a movie 'cause he's bound to be great in it. He gives so much of himself in each role, both physically and mentally, that he's a joy to watch.